New Roof Still Leaking When It Rains Hard? Here's What That Usually Means

A new roof that leaks only in heavy rain usually points to one of a few things: installation defects (flashing, valleys, penetrations), storm damage that occurred after installation (wind-driven rain, hail, lifted shingles), or a pre-existing structural issue the new roof didn't fix. Which one it is matters a lot, because it determines whether this is a warranty issue with your roofer, a homeowners insurance claim, or both. The only way to know is to get underneath the leak and onto the roof surface to trace the actual entry point — guessing from the ceiling stain alone rarely tells the real story.

How this affects your insurance claim

If a storm event — wind, wind-driven rain, or hail — happened between installation and when the leaking started, this may be a covered insurance claim rather than just a contractor callback. Before anyone patches, re-flashes, or reseals anything, the roof and the interior damage need to be documented exactly as they are now. Once repairs start, the evidence that ties the leak to a specific storm date can disappear.

What to do now

• Photograph and date the interior water stain, drip point, or damage as soon as you notice it, and again after each heavy rain.
• Photograph the roof itself from the ground (and by drone or ladder if safe) — flashing, valleys, vents, and any visible lifted or missing shingles.
• Place a bucket or tarp to catch water and protect flooring or belongings, but avoid cutting into drywall or removing roofing material yet.
• Note the date of every rain event that caused leaking, and check local weather records for wind speeds or hail on those dates.
• Locate your roof installation invoice, warranty paperwork, and any contractor communication.
• Do not authorize permanent roof repair or re-roofing until the leak source and cause have been documented.

What the insurance company will need

• Roof installation contract, invoice, and any manufacturer or workmanship warranty
• Dated photos/video of the interior leak location, including the first time it appeared
• Dated photos of the roof surface — flashing, valleys, vents, ridge, and any visible damage
• Local weather data (wind speed, hail reports) for the date(s) leaking occurred
• Any inspection or punch-list report from the roof installer or a third-party inspector
• Correspondence with the roofing contractor about the leak
• Prior roof inspection or certification report if one exists (e.g., from closing or permitting)
• Repair estimates from a licensed roofer describing the suspected cause
• Interior damage documentation — flooring, drywall, insulation, personal property affected

What your insurance may or may not cover

Whether this is covered depends on the cause, not just the fact that water got in. Homeowners policies generally address sudden, accidental water intrusion from a covered peril — like wind or hail damage to roofing components — differently than they treat faulty workmanship, which is typically excluded and falls back on the roofer's warranty. Some policies also draw a line around water intrusion tied to construction defects versus storm-caused openings. The actual wording in your policy, and the timeline between installation and the leak, will control the answer.

What could reduce or defeat the claim

The most common dispute on a leaking new roof is the insurer attributing the leak to "faulty workmanship" or "improper installation" rather than storm damage, since both can look identical from a ceiling stain. Insurers may also point to a pre-existing condition, argue the leak has been ongoing and unreported, or say there's insufficient evidence connecting the water intrusion to a specific date or event. Without documentation tying the leak to a storm, this dispute is difficult to win.

Should you file a claim?

If the leak began after a specific storm with wind or hail, or if a roof inspection shows storm-related damage (lifted shingles, hail bruising, damaged flashing) rather than a clean installation error, it's worth having the loss reviewed for a possible claim. If a roofer's own inspection clearly shows a workmanship defect unrelated to weather — like a missed nail pattern or unsealed penetration with no storm nearby — this may be a warranty matter rather than an insurance one, and a public adjuster review may not change that outcome.

How a public adjuster helps in this situation

Public Loss Adjusters investigates the actual cause of the leak — reviewing the roof, the installation records, weather data, and the interior damage — to determine whether a storm event contributed to the intrusion and how that intersects with your policy's language. If there's a legitimate claim, the firm documents the loss, prepares the estimate, and presents and negotiates the claim with the insurer on your behalf, separate from any warranty conversation you may also need to have with the roofer.

When you may not need a public adjuster

If the leak is minor, clearly tied to a workmanship error the roofer already agrees to fix under warranty, and there's no storm event involved, a public adjuster review may add little — this is likely better resolved directly with the contractor.

Frequently asked questions

Why does my new roof leak when it rains hard but not when it drizzles?

Heavy, wind-driven rain can push water into small gaps around flashing, vents, or valleys that light rain never reaches. It can point to an installation gap or storm damage that only shows itself under pressure.

Is a leak in a brand-new roof covered by insurance or by the roofer's warranty?

It depends on the cause. Storm-related damage (wind, hail) may fall under your homeowners policy; installation defects are typically a warranty matter with the roofing contractor. Sometimes both are relevant.

How can I tell if my new roof leak is from bad installation or storm damage?

Usually only a roof inspection paired with weather data for the date the leak started can tell the difference — the interior stain alone looks the same either way.

Should I call my roofer or my insurance company first?

Document everything first — photos, dates, weather records. Then you can pursue both the warranty conversation and, if a storm is involved, an insurance review, without losing evidence.

Will my insurance company deny a leak claim on a new roof because it's new?

A roof's age doesn't automatically bar a claim, but insurers often scrutinize new-roof leaks closely for signs of installation defects, which are commonly excluded.

What if there was a storm around the time my new roof started leaking?

That timeline matters. If wind or hail occurred close to when the leak began, it strengthens the case that this may be storm-related damage rather than a workmanship issue.

Can I get my roof repaired and file an insurance claim later?

Repairing first can remove the evidence needed to prove what caused the leak. It's safer to document the damage and get a coverage review before permanent repairs happen.

My roof was just installed and it's already leaking — is that normal?

It's not something to ignore. A recently installed roof leaking in heavy rain warrants an inspection to identify whether it's a workmanship issue, damaged material, or a new storm-caused opening.

What does a roofer usually say when a new roof leaks?

Roofers often attribute leaks to something outside their installation — pre-existing conditions, storm damage, or ventilation issues — which is one reason independent documentation matters.

Do I need a public adjuster for a new roof leak?

Only if there's a reasonable chance the leak is tied to a covered peril like wind or hail. A public adjuster reviews the facts and policy to help determine if that's the case.

What is a public adjuster and why would I need one for a roof leak?

A public adjuster represents you, the policyholder, rather than the insurance company, and helps document and present a property claim. Most people learn about the role only after realizing their claim is more complicated than expected.

How long do I have to file an insurance claim for a roof leak in Florida?

Florida law places time limits on filing property claims and any supplemental claims, so it's important not to delay once you suspect storm-related damage — an adjuster can confirm your specific deadlines.

What if my roof passed inspection but is still leaking now?

A prior inspection or certification doesn't rule out later storm damage. If leaking started after a specific weather event, that's a separate issue from what was inspected at installation.

Can hail cause a new roof to leak even if I don't see obvious damage?

Yes. Hail can bruise or crack shingles and loosen flashing seals in ways that aren't visible from the ground but allow water intrusion during heavy rain.

What should I photograph before getting my new roof leak repaired?

The interior stain or drip point, the roof surface (flashing, valleys, vents, shingles), and anything unusual like lifted or missing materials — all dated, ideally before and after each rain event.

Does homeowners insurance cover faulty roof installation?

Generally no — faulty workmanship is typically excluded and is a matter for the roofing contractor's warranty, not the insurance policy. Coverage usually applies to damage from a covered peril, not defective work.

What does 'no recovery, no fee' mean for a roof leak claim?

It means the public adjuster's fee, which is capped by Florida law as a percentage of the claim payment, is only owed if there's a recovery on the claim.

Can I still file a claim if I already had the leak temporarily patched?

Possibly, but the more original evidence that's preserved — photos, the removed materials, dates — the stronger the documentation for a claim. Let an adjuster know what's already been altered.

Send photos of the ceiling stain or drip, the roof itself if you have them, and your roof installation date — along with your policy if available — for a free review of whether this may be a storm-related claim.

Related: Parent Hub · Claim Process · Sibling · Sibling